Since being elected, I have been consistent in my view that new housing must come with the infrastructure needed to support it.
I have always taken the view that the Local Plan, and decisions around sites such as Exmo20, are matters for East Devon District Council and its elected councillors. It is their responsibility to carry out that important work, make difficult decisions and ultimately be accountable to local people for them.
However, I have received an overwhelming amount of correspondence from residents about Exmo20. As concerns have grown, I have become increasingly uneasy not only about the proposals themselves, but also about the way legitimate questions and challenges have been handled. That is why I have become more directly involved.
We need new homes. We need good local developers to help us deliver genuinely affordable homes so that the next generation has the opportunity to live near their families, friends and places of work.
Building homes is, in many ways, the relatively straightforward part. The problems arise when the wrong sites are chosen, or when too little thought is given to the infrastructure that must accompany development - roads, schools, healthcare, sewage treatment, transport links and the proper adoption of new roads and public spaces.
I have seen the consequences of getting this wrong across Exmouth and Exeter East. It is local people, families and communities who ultimately pay the price - and I will not let that happen on my watch.
That is why I have repeatedly argued for an βinfrastructure-firstβ approach to development. I welcome the fact that there is now greater cross-party agreement locally on that principle.
This should not be a party-political issue. We should be able to work together to make sure development happens in the right places and that communities have the infrastructure they need.
But working together also requires accountability.
I have been critical of councillors in leadership positions when their response to difficult questions appears to be that they have little choice because they are simply carrying out the wishes of central government.
If you genuinely believe you have no agency, what is the point of standing for election?
Councillors are elected to exercise judgement, represent their communities, challenge decisions where necessary and use the powers available to them. I do not expect them to control everything. I do expect them to stand up for our area and take responsibility for the decisions they can influence.
But the debate around Exmo20 has exposed a far more insidious side to EDDC and its leadership.
I have seen lies, obfuscation and attempts to shut down people who ask difficult questions.
I first saw this in the way local campaigner Mr Shillitoe was treated after raising concerns about Exmo20 at a Strategic Planning Committee meeting.
When I raised the matter with EDDC, a senior officer told me that some of the comments made had questioned the βprofessional competence and integrityβ of a senior Council officer, and that it was βnot acceptable to verbally attack individual officers or members of the Council in a public settingβ.
That is a serious description, and the bar for calling something a βverbal attackβ should be a high one. Local people must be able to question the Councilβs processes, challenge the evidence being relied upon and scrutinise the conclusions being presented to elected members. Robust scrutiny should not automatically be characterised as a personal attack.
There were also problems with the recording of the meeting. Sections were redacted and, after concerns were raised, a senior officer upheld a complaint about one of those redactions. The Council also acknowledged that the original footage had been edited, meaning the deleted section could not be restored.
EDDC apologised, changed its process for retaining original footage, and amended the draft minutes so that Mr Shillitoeβs comments would remain on the official record.
That should concern people.
I then received similar treatment after asking legitimate questions about Exmo20 and the infrastructure that would accompany it.
Cllr Paul Arnott, the Liberal Democrat Leader of EDDC, claimed during a council meeting that I had βtrouseredβ money from a local developer shortly after being elected.
That statement is one hundred per cent untrue.
I complained to the Council. The relevant video was then redacted, while Cllr Arnottβs allegation was left to circulate within the community. I have also been threatened with potential legal action if I communicate details of the investigation involving Cllr Arnott.
That is not transparency. It is not accountability. And it is not acceptable from the leadership of a local authority.
When elected representatives are asked difficult but legitimate questions, the response should be facts, evidence and openness - not lies, smears and redactions.
What makes this even more serious is that the allegations did not stop there.
Cllr Charlotte FitzGerald - a Liberal Democrat councillor, a member of EDDCβs Strategic Planning Committee and now the Liberal Democrat parliamentary candidate for Exmouth and Exeter East - went on to repeat the allegation publicly, including in material sent to journalists, claiming that just after my election I had accepted thousands of pounds from the developer.
When confronted with the facts, the response was to backtrack and obfuscate rather than simply admit that the allegation was wrong.
Honesty and integrity in public life matter. Telling the truth matters.
Politics can be robust. We can disagree strongly about housing, planning, infrastructure and the future of our communities. That is democracy.
But there has to be a line.
Making false allegations about people who challenge you does not answer legitimate questions about Exmo20. Mudslinging does not remove the responsibility of elected representatives to explain the decisions being taken on behalf of the communities they serve.
And that brings me back to the central point.
We all care deeply about our home and about how Exmouth & Exeter East and the surrounding area develop in the years ahead. There should be constructive, cross-party engagement on something as important as this.
I do not want this debate to become one of political point-scoring. I want councillors, MPs, developers and local people to be able to work together constructively and get the best possible outcome for our area.
